Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Consignment Furniture Store in Oyster Bay, NY
Since 1969, Attic Door Furniture has served Long Island as a family-owned consignment shop specializing in high-quality furniture and home decor. Our legacy began with our grandmother's commitment to excellence and continues through generations of personalized service. We pride ourselves on curating an ever-changing inventory that balances timeless treasures with contemporary trends. Our team handles every consignment with meticulous care, from free appraisals to same-day pickups by family members. With over 50 years of expertise, we ensure both sellers and buyers receive exceptional value through competitive pricing and transparent processes. Our Oyster Bay storefront operates Tuesday through Saturday, offering a dynamic shopping experience where unique pieces find new homes quickly.We prioritize customer satisfaction through daily social media updates and direct communication throughout the consignment journey. Our deep understanding of furniture trends and market demands ensures optimal pricing for every item we showcase. As an environmentally conscious business, we promote sustainable practices by extending the lifecycle of quality home furnishings. Whether you're downsizing, relocating, or seeking distinctive decor, our family welcomes you to experience the Attic Door difference firsthand.
Services
Furniture Consignment
Home Decor Sales
Estate Liquidation
Furniture Appraisals
Interior Accessories
Details
- Year established: 1969
Highlights and features
- Family-owned operation with 50+ years of furniture expertise
- Free in-home appraisals and same-day pickups by family members
- Sellers receive 50% profit on all sales immediately after purchase
- Daily Instagram updates showcase our constantly rotating inventory
- Specialize in matching estate sale needs with environmentally conscious solutions
What people say
Unique inventory
Knowledgeable staff
Efficient consignment process
Family expertise
Personalized service
Services
Furniture Consignment
Our furniture consignment service offers sellers 50% profit on sales with free appraisals and same-day pickups. Family members handle all transactions directly, ensuring personalized service. Items typically sell within a week through our physical store and social media exposure.
Home Decor Sales
We curate an ever-changing selection of decorative home accessories that combine modern trends with timeless pieces. Our inventory includes artwork, lighting fixtures, and accent pieces that sell quickly due to our market expertise. Each item undergoes careful selection to maintain quality standards.
Estate Liquidation
Our estate liquidation service provides socially responsible alternatives to traditional sales platforms. We handle complete home clearances with professional discretion, offering competitive pricing and direct family communication throughout the process. This service includes transportation and itemized inventory tracking.
Furniture Appraisals
We offer free furniture appraisals with immediate market value assessments. Clients can submit photos via email or schedule in-home evaluations. Our pricing strategy combines 50 years of market knowledge with current trend analysis to maximize seller returns.
Interior Accessories
Our interior accessories collection features hand-selected decorative items that complement both modern and traditional spaces. The inventory rotates daily with new arrivals showcased through social media updates. We specialize in unique pieces that enhance residential environments while maintaining functional value.
People
Mark Tiberio
Owner
Third-generation furniture expert with over 25 years of consignment experience. Specializes in market trend analysis and pricing strategy. Directly oversees inventory selection and customer relations at the Oyster Bay location.
Brian Tiberio
Owner
Family business leader focused on operational efficiency and client communication. Manages logistics and transportation services for consignment items. Brings 20+ years of hands-on experience in furniture evaluation and estate services.
Questions
What types of items do you accept for consignment?
We accept quality furniture, artwork, and decorative home accessories. Our selection focuses on marketable items that align with current trends and timeless design.
How long does it take for items to sell?
Most items sell within a week through our physical store or social media exposure. We price items competitively based on condition and market demand.
What payment options are available?
Sellers receive 50% of the sale price immediately after purchase. Payments can be collected in person or mailed directly to the account holder.
Do you offer delivery services?
We provide free pickup services for consignment items. Delivery options for purchased items are available through separate arrangements with local movers.
What makes your consignment service unique?
Our family-owned business combines 50+ years of expertise with direct communication throughout the process. We handle all transactions personally without third-party intermediaries.
